A cream stucco estate with a terracotta roof sits beyond a quiet pond, framed by palms, green lawn and dense South Florida vegetation.

Buying in Palm Beach Polo While the Golf Is Rebuilt Next Door

  • November 19, 2026

A lakefront house on Cypress Island Way changed hands this month for $6 million. It is a 5,900-square-foot home built in 2012 on 0.64 acres, and it had been listed at $6.5 million. The Real Deal reported that the sellers paid $5.9 million for it in 2021. Five years of Wellington's strongest attention from wealthy buyers moved the price of a lake-view estate in Palm Beach Polo by $100,000.

The sale makes sense once you look at what a buyer inside Palm Beach Polo's gates is paying for today. Palm Beach Polo still carries the words "Golf & Country Club," but its golf is either closed or now belongs to someone else. Values are set by the enclave, the lot and what the back of the house faces. Two large projects on former Palm Beach Polo golf land will reach completion between late 2028 and 2029, so anyone buying this winter is pricing a home before those new comparables exist.

Where Palm Beach Polo's golf went

Glenn Straub has owned the club since he bought it at auction in 1993. The course closures came in stages. According to Golf Course Architecture, the North course closed in 1999, the Dunes in 2018 and Polo West in 2019. The East Course has been closed since 2000.

In April 2023, Mark Bellissimo paid Straub $35 million for the 126-acre Cypress course at 11934 South Shore Boulevard, with part of the price financed by Straub, The Real Deal reported. Golf Course Architecture now lists that land as part of The Wellington, the 400-acre club community run by Wellington Lifestyle Partners.

What the Palm Beach Polo Property Owners Association promotes today is closer to a racquet and wellness club: eight clay tennis courts, four pickleball courts, croquet, fitness and wellness facilities, and onsite physical therapy support. For a serious golfer, that changes what the address delivers. For a rider, a tennis player or a family that wants a gated estate a short drive from Wellington International, little changes.

Two estate sales, priced on the lot

Two recent estate sales inside the gates were large enough to make the trade press. Both closed far closer to what the sellers originally paid than to their asking prices.

Street Lot Home size Seller's purchase Reported ask Sale Price per sq. ft.
Hurlingham Drive 0.9 acres 7,300 sq. ft. $7.8M, 2013 $16M, 2024 $10M, Sept. 2025 about $1,370
Cypress Island Way 0.64 acres 5,900 sq. ft. $5.9M, 2021 $6.5M $6M, Nov. 2026 about $1,020

The Hurlingham Drive house was built in 1998 and borders the 92-acre Cypress Preserve, according to The Real Deal. It sold for $10 million in September 2025, after being listed at $16 million the year before. That sale came in at 62.5% of the earlier ask, and the price was about 28% above what the sellers paid twelve years earlier. The Cypress Island Way sale came in at about 92% of its ask and about 1.7% above the sellers' 2021 price.

Across all of Wellington, single-family sellers received 94.8% of their original list price in the third quarter of 2026, and the median time to contract was 44 days, according to Florida Realtors' Q3 2026 local market metrics. The same report shows 305 active single-family listings in the village for the quarter, or 5.0 months of supply. Those figures cover every price point, with a village median sale price of $755,000 for the quarter. So they are context for these two sales, not a benchmark for them. Still, both Palm Beach Polo estates sold below the village's typical ratio to list, and one sold far below it.

The more useful number is per square foot. The Hurlingham Drive house is the older home, yet it brought roughly $350 more per square foot than the newer house on Cypress Island Way. It sits on a larger lot and backs onto the Cypress Preserve. At this end of Palm Beach Polo, buyers are paying for the land and what it faces, and the age of the house matters less.

The enclave sets the comparable

Palm Beach Polo has more than 1,300 residences in more than 40 subcommunities, and many have their own neighborhood or condominium association. The POA groups them into four types. The estate enclaves include Bridle Path, Blue Cypress, Cypress Island, Fairway Island, Golf Brook and Kensington. Patio homes are in Bent Cypress, Chukker Cove, Muir Villas and Polo Island. Townhomes are in Las Casitas, Wimbledon and Windsor Way. The condo communities include Cowdray Park, Hurlingham, La Quinta, Pebblewood and Tennis Lodges.

Because of that structure, a community-wide average tells a buyer almost nothing. A condo in Pebblewood and a lakefront estate on Cypress Island share a gate and a name, but they do not compete for the same buyer. A sound offer starts with sales in the same enclave, then narrows to the same exposure, whether that is lake, preserve or a former fairway. Because many subcommunities have their own association, get the association figures for the specific property in writing before you put a number on paper.

Some enclave names, such as Golf Brook and Fairway Island, describe a view that was laid out around golf. On those streets, a buyer should find out who owns the land behind the house today and what has been proposed for it.

The new neighbors arrive between 2028 and 2029

The East Course parcel is the clearest example of former golf land getting a new use. Developer Joe Farrell bought the 23-acre site from Straub in 2023 for $12.6 million, according to The Real Deal. Farrell Estates is planned there with 27 homes priced from $5 million to $10 million. The plans call for two-story homes of 5,300 to 8,900 square feet with oversized garages and golf cart bays. A $49 million construction loan was arranged in October, construction has started, and final buildout is expected in September 2029.

These will be the first newly built homes inside the gates priced in the same range as the two estate sales above. As each one closes, buyers and appraisers will have a recent new-construction comparable to set beside every resale in the estate enclaves. Today that set of comparables is thin.

The Wellington, on the other side of the former golf land, runs on a similar schedule. Golf Course Architecture reports that David McLay Kidd's new 18-hole course will be laid out on 136 acres. Construction is expected to begin in March 2027, with play by December 2028. Kidd says the property "began life as one of the three golf courses in the Palm Beach Polo & Country Club." NEXUS Luxury Collection, backed by Tiger Woods, Ernie Els and Justin Timberlake, is an investor and the operating partner. The Wellington is planned for 253 residences. CW34 reported in April that more than $10 million in infrastructure work was underway and that the project is aiming for a 2028 opening.

The club's Founder's program, launched in January 2025, is aimed at families joining the club community and building a home there, as The Chronicle of the Horse reported. If a Palm Beach Polo buyer wants golf, the question about access to The Wellington should go to Wellington Lifestyle Partners directly, in writing. A buyer who does not want golf can treat the course as a neighboring landscape that will be finished by the end of 2028.

What this means for an offer this season

A buyer in the estate enclaves this winter is pricing a lot, a frontage and a house against a few recent resales. Those resales show patient sellers accepting prices well below their opening asks. The two sales in the table show how far negotiation inside the gates can move, and an offer should be built on enclave-level comparables rather than the asking price alone.

Water and preserve frontage are the features the recent prices rewarded. A buyer comparing a Cypress Island lake lot with a lot on a street named for a fairway should know which of those views is protected and which faces land that may change. The preserve side has history of its own. In 2023, the POA took a lease on 92.4 acres of Big Blue for $100 a year and took on the wetland maintenance, the Palm Beach Post reported. A buyer should ask the POA directly what that arrangement means for the specific lot.

Timing also matters. A home bought this winter will hold its value through the years when 27 new homes go up on the old East Course and a Kidd course is built next door. The seller who bought on Cypress Island in 2021 held for five years and came out about even. A buyer who expects to hold through 2029 will own through the period when those new comparables are set.

For buyers weighing a gated estate against acreage, our guide to choosing between a gated community and a farm in Wellington covers the trade-offs. Current inventory is on our Wellington homes for sale page.

FAQ

Is there an operating golf course inside Palm Beach Polo? The North, Dunes and Polo West courses closed in 1999, 2018 and 2019, the East Course has been closed since 2000, and the Cypress course was sold in 2023. The closest new course is the one planned at The Wellington, with play expected by December 2028.

Where is Farrell Estates? It is inside the gated Palm Beach Polo community, on the 23-acre site of the former East Course.

Do Palm Beach Polo homes share one set of association fees? The community is made up of more than 40 subcommunities, and many have their own neighborhood or condominium association, so confirm the association figures for the specific property.

If you are weighing an estate on Cypress Island, Hurlingham Drive or any of Palm Beach Polo's enclaves, or thinking about selling one before the new homes arrive, Matt Johnson would welcome a quiet conversation about that enclave, its frontage and what this season's sales suggest. Request a Private Consultation.

Work with Matt

Bringing passion, dedication, and resources to help clients reach their buying and selling goals. 

Follow Me on Instagram